Science 2.0 - Evolving the Scientific Method in the Age of AI

-
Lior Horesh, IBM
Fine Hall 214

Joint Colloquium with CSML

The scientific method has driven humanity's intellectual advancement for centuries. Yet growing concerns about scientific stagnation demand fundamental reexamination of its foundations. The emergence of large-scale AI systems (statistical, generative, and symbolic) presents both unprecedented opportunity and necessity to reconceptualize scientific discovery itself. 

Historically, scientific models emerged through manual, first-principles deductive approaches that yielded interpretable symbolic frameworks with remarkable universality despite limited data. While time-consuming and expertise-dependent, these methods contrast sharply with modern data-driven techniques that enable rapid automated development but often produce non-interpretable models requiring extensive training data with poor out-of-distribution generalization. 

This lecture explores emerging approaches to mathematical model discovery that transcend this historical divide by connecting inductive, data-driven techniques with deductive, knowledge-based reasoning. We highlight two hybrid frameworks: AI-Descartes, a generator-verifier paradigm that couples hypothesis induction with deductive formal validation against background theory, and AI-Hilbert, which unifies hypothesis generation and testing into a single process. We also introduce an algebraic-geometric perspective on model discovery and discuss AI-Noether, a framework for revising background theory itself via abductive reasoning. 

Ultimately, we advocate for a conceptual evolution of the scientific method, beyond mere automation, toward deeper integration of AI in the pursuit of interpretable, generalizable models.